Best Pizza Places in New York

Discover the best pizza places in New York! Explore top pizzerias offering delicious, authentic slices in the heart of the city.

READ ALSO: Best Pizza Places in New York / Best lingerie brands in Canada / Best lipstick brands in Canada / Best guitar brands in Canada / Best golf brands in Canada

NYC pizza is legendary. Pizza aficionados have several options in the city due to its rich history and diverse culture. Check out New York’s top five pizza spots:

1. Di Fara Pizza

Since 1965, Domenico DeMarco and his family have managed Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn, a beloved pizza establishment. San Marzano tomatoes and Italian olive oil are used to make this real Italian-style pizza. A flawless crust is guaranteed by hand-preparing the dough daily.

Try the Di Fara Special, a classic with sausage, fresh basil, and cheeses. Expect long lineups, but this legendary restaurant’s flavor and old-school charm are worth it.

2. Joe’s Pizza

Joe’s Pizza serves classic New York pizza. Joe’s, open since 1975, is known for its thin-crust, foldable slices. No-frills menu is basic done right.

Every piece of pizza—plain cheese or pepperoni—recalls NYC. Here, tourists and residents gather, and its multiple sites make it accessible throughout the city.

3. Lucali

Lucali, located in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, offers a pleasant, rustic ambiance with delicious pizza. Lucali, founded by Mark Iacono to preserve the neighborhood’s pizza history, is now one of NYC’s most famous restaurants.

Lucali only serves huge, thin-crust pizzas with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and toppings like pepperoni, basil, and garlic. BYOB (bring your own beverage) makes meals more personal.

No reservations, so arrive early to secure your position.

4. Prince Street Pizza

Located in Nolita, Manhattan, Prince Street Pizza is known for its thick, square-shaped Sicilian slices. Their hot spring pizza, with crispy, cupped pepperoni and spicy marinara sauce, is a NYC classic.

The abundant toppings and crispy-doughy crust satisfy. Fast service keeps the small shop’s line short.

5. Roberta’s

Modern pizza lovers love Roberta’s wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pizzas. This creative warehouse restaurant serves excellent pizza in a casual setting.

Bee Sting pizza, made with spicy soppressata, mozzarella, and honey, is a unique blend of sweet and savory. Roberta’s provides great salads and sides, making it ideal for group outings.

Their pizzas are available for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, satisfying all tastes.

New York City has the best pizza, from thin crust to artisanal. These five spots provide different pizza experiences, so there’s something for everyone. Explore these classic spots and sample NYC’s greatest slices, whether you’re visiting or a local.